Outsourced IT vs In-House IT for a Small Business
How to choose between hiring an IT person and an outsourced IT support provider, the hidden costs of each option and the questions to ask first.
Published 10 min read
Sooner or later every small business faces the same question: do we hire an IT person, or do we work with an outside IT company? It usually comes up after a bad week, with a server down and three people unable to work. This article covers what an IT person actually does in a small company, when each option makes sense, and what to check before you sign a contract or make a hire.
What IT work looks like in a small company
Before you decide who does the work, it helps to know what the work is. In an office with anywhere from a handful to a few dozen people, IT looks roughly like this:
- Day-to-day support. Forgotten passwords, the printer that has vanished, Outlook not syncing, a new monitor to connect.
- Preventive maintenance. Windows and software updates, checking the backup, the antivirus and free disk space.
- Accounts and access. A new starter needs an email account, access to shared folders and licences. A leaver needs all of that closed on the same day.
- Network and equipment. Router, switch, Wi-Fi, NAS or server, printers, UPS.
- Purchasing and planning. Which computers to buy, when to replace them, which licences you’ll need next year.
- Incidents. A virus, a phishing email someone clicked, a failing disk.
Some months there’s almost nothing to do. Others bring an office move or ransomware. That variation matters a lot when you choose. If you’d like to see how maintenance work is usually divided up, the page on what maintenance means in IT explains it briefly.
When an in-house IT person makes sense
Having your own IT person is the right call when there’s enough daily work for them and when being physically present matters. A few signs:
- You have enough people and equipment that support requests come in every day, not once a week.
- You use industry-specific software (production, laboratory, logistics) that needs someone who knows it in depth.
- You have several sites or work in shifts, and someone has to be there in person.
- IT is part of what your company sells, not just part of the back office.
An employee knows the people, knows who does what, and fixes small things quickly. That’s real value.
The limit is that they’re one person. Nobody can be an expert in networks, security, servers, Microsoft licensing and printers all at once. They also take holidays and sick days, and at some point they may leave.
When outsourced IT support makes sense
For most small businesses, IT work doesn’t fill a full-time role. That’s where outsourced IT maintenance comes in: a company that looks after your computers, network and servers under contract, remotely, and on site when needed.
This option fits when:
- support requests are irregular and don’t justify a full salary;
- you need knowledge across several areas, not one specialist;
- you want someone watching the backup, updates and security even in quiet months;
- you don’t want your whole infrastructure to depend on one person.
An outside provider has its drawbacks too. They’re not in the office all day, so problems that need hands on the equipment wait for a visit. They won’t know your people as well from day one. And quality depends heavily on how clearly the contract is written, which we cover in the article on what an IT maintenance contract should include.
What each option really costs
We won’t give you figures, because they depend on too many factors. We can tell you what goes into the calculation, so you compare like with like.
For an in-house IT employee
- salary and employer contributions, all year round, including the months with no problems;
- their computer, licences and tools (inventory, remote access and monitoring software);
- training: technology moves on, and someone who stops learning falls behind within a few years;
- cover for absences: who fixes things while they’re on holiday;
- the cost of them leaving: the time a newcomer needs to learn what the previous person left behind, especially if there’s no documentation.
For an outsourced provider
- the monthly fee, which usually depends on the number of computers, users and servers;
- the promised response time: a same-day response costs more than one within three days;
- on-site visits, included or billed separately;
- large projects (a new server, an office move), usually billed separately;
- parts and licences, which you pay for either way.
Compare the total cost over a year, not a salary against a monthly fee. And weigh up what happens on the bad day: how long the business stands still if the IT person isn’t available.
The risk of the “colleague who’s good with computers”
Many small businesses have neither an IT employee nor a provider. They have a colleague who’s “good with computers”: an enthusiastic accountant, the owner’s nephew, a former employee who still drops by. It works, until one day it doesn’t.
The problems always appear in the same places:
- The passwords live in one person’s head. The router, the Microsoft 365 admin account, the NAS, the website’s domain. If that person leaves or stops answering, the company loses access to its own systems.
- There’s no documentation. Nobody knows what’s configured, where or why.
- The boring jobs don’t get done. The backup isn’t checked, updates get postponed, former employees’ accounts stay active.
Whichever option you choose, insist on two things: a written list of equipment and accounts, and admin passwords that the company also holds, somewhere safe. A password manager for your team takes care of the second part without anyone keeping them on paper.
The hybrid model
You don’t have to pick one or the other. Many companies combine the two:
- Someone in-house for the small stuff. A person in the office, not necessarily an IT specialist, who’s the first point of contact: restarts the printer, swaps a toner, calls the provider.
- The outsourced provider for everything else. Network, servers, backup, security, purchasing, incidents.
Larger companies often do it the other way round: an IT employee handles daily support, and an outside provider covers specialist work (security, servers, projects) and steps in while the employee is away.
What matters in a hybrid setup is that everyone knows who does what. Write it down, or each side will assume the other one checked the backup.
How to choose an outsourced IT provider
If you go the outsourced route, a few questions separate a good provider from one that just answers the phone:
- How do you start? A serious start means an assessment and an inventory: what equipment you have, which licences, where the data lives, how the backup runs.
- What do you do preventively? Updates, monitoring, backup checks. If the provider only appears when you call, you’re paying for repairs, not maintenance.
- Who holds the access? Admin passwords must stay with you as well.
- What do we get each month? A short report on what was done and what’s next.
- How do we part ways? The contract should say you receive all documentation and all access at the end.
Concrete examples of services you can ask for are on the page listing examples of IT services.
How to switch without losing anything
Moving from an employee to a provider, or the other way round, is riskiest at the handover. A few simple steps:
- List every admin account: router, Microsoft 365 or email, domain, website, NAS, server, antivirus, accounting software.
- Change the passwords after the handover and check that the new person in charge can get into each one.
- Check the backup with a test restore, not just a report. The method is explained in the article on the 3-2-1 backup rule for small businesses.
- Note down licences and expiry dates: Windows, Office, antivirus, certificates, domain.
- Shut off the previous person’s remote access if they no longer work with you.
The same kind of list helps whenever an ordinary employee leaves, a topic we cover separately in the article on employee onboarding and offboarding accounts.
Signs your current setup isn’t enough
Sometimes you don’t need to choose from scratch. You need to recognise that what you have can’t keep up. A few common warning signs:
- The same problem keeps coming back. The printer drops off the network every month, the Wi-Fi fails in the same meeting room. Someone fixes it, but nobody looks for the cause.
- Nobody can answer “when was the last good backup?” If you have to ask three people, the backup has no owner.
- Staff are fixing things themselves. They install programs found online, open personal cloud accounts for company files, plug in their own router. That means official support is too slow or too hard to ask for.
- Purchases are made in a rush. A computer gets bought when the old one dies, not according to a plan. The result is a mix of models and licences, and more maintenance work.
- The IT person is always firefighting. Once there’s no time for updates and checks, the preventive work is the first thing to go.
Any of these is a reason to review how IT is organised. Sometimes the answer is an outside provider alongside your existing employee. Sometimes it’s a clearer contract with the provider you already have. And sometimes the problem isn’t who does the work, it’s that nobody ever wrote down what needs doing.
Frequently asked questions
At what company size does an in-house IT person make sense?
There’s no fixed threshold. What matters more is how many support requests come in each day, how complex your software is, and whether someone needs to be physically in the office. A small office running standard software usually manages well with an outside provider, while a company with production or several sites may need someone in-house.
Can an outside IT company fix problems remotely?
Many of them, yes: Windows settings, email, software, accounts, network printers. Cables, faulty parts and new equipment still need someone on site. Ask the provider how many visits are included and how quickly they can get to you.
What happens to our company data with an outside provider?
The provider has access to your systems, so the contract needs to cover confidentiality and, if they can see personal data, the rules for processing it. The data stays the company’s, and at the end you must get all access back.
Can we keep our colleague who’s good with computers and add a provider?
Yes, and it’s a good option. The colleague stays the first point of contact for small things, and the provider handles backup, security and the network. Just agree in writing who does what, so nothing falls through the gap.
What does an IT employee do every day?
It depends on the company, but usually support for colleagues, accounts, updates, equipment and purchasing. We’ve described IT job responsibilities in detail on a separate page.
When to ask for an assessment
If you’re not sure which option suits you, start with an assessment. We look at what equipment you have, how the backup works, who holds the passwords and how many problems come up in a normal month. Then we tell you honestly whether an outside contract is enough, whether you need someone in-house, or a combination of the two.
TECH Consult has provided IT maintenance for small and medium businesses for over 25 years: computers, servers, networks and software. Our IT maintenance page explains what working with us usually includes and how to get in touch.