Skip to content
TECH Consult

Compatible vs Original Ink Cartridges for Your Home Printer

The real differences between original, compatible and refilled ink cartridges, the risks to your printer and how to work out cost per page before you buy.

Published 10 min read

Original cartridges sometimes cost almost as much as the printer, and right next to them on the shelf sit compatible cartridges for the same model at a fraction of the price. It’s a fair question: is the saving worth it, or are you risking the printer and print quality? The answer depends on how much you print, what you print and which printer you have. Below you’ll find the real differences, the risks, how to compare prices properly and what alternatives you have.

What each type of cartridge means

Shops and websites use several labels, and they don’t mean the same thing:

  • Original (OEM): made by the printer manufacturer, with the exact model code.
  • Compatible: new, made by another company, copying the shape and chip of the original.
  • Remanufactured: a used original cartridge that a specialist company has emptied, cleaned, refilled and sometimes fitted with new parts, then sells again.
  • Refilled: your own cartridge, filled up again with ink, at a shop or at home with a kit.
  • CISS (continuous ink supply system): external tanks connected to the cartridges by tubes. On many models it’s a makeshift setup.

Separate from all of these are ink tank printers, which don’t use cartridges at all and are filled from bottles. More on those below.

How to find the right cartridge code

Most wrong cartridges get bought because printers have similar names. The cartridge code isn’t the same as the printer’s name.

You’ll find it in a few places:

  1. On the old cartridge, on its label. That’s the safest place.
  2. In the printer manual or on the support page for the exact model, under supplies.
  3. In the printer’s menu or its software on the computer, next to the ink levels, where some models also show the code.
  4. On the label on the back or underneath the printer, which gives the exact model with every letter. Use that to search for the cartridge.

Watch out for two traps. Some printers sold in different regions only accept cartridges for their own region, even when they look identical. And the “starter” cartridges that ship with a new printer are usually smaller than standard ones, so they run out sooner. Don’t judge your usage by how long they last.

What you pay for with an original cartridge

The high price of an original isn’t just the ink. You’re paying for:

  • Guaranteed compatibility. The printer recognises it, shows no warnings and has no surprises after updates.
  • Ink formulated for the print head. Viscosity, drying time and pigments are tuned for that printer.
  • Consistent quality from one cartridge to the next.
  • Print longevity. Original inks are designed to work with the same manufacturer’s photo paper, so photos don’t fade quickly.

On many home printers, the print head is built into the cartridge. That means every new cartridge brings a new print head too. A poor compatible cartridge, though, also comes with a poor print head.

The risks of compatible cartridges

Plenty of compatible cartridges work well. Problems do happen, but not everywhere and not equally often. The most common:

  • The printer doesn’t recognise the cartridge. The chip isn’t accepted and the printer refuses to print or shows warnings.
  • Firmware updates. Some manufacturers push updates that can block certain compatible cartridges that worked until then. If you use compatibles, don’t accept printer updates blindly. Read what they contain and, if needed, turn off automatic updates in the printer’s menu.
  • Ink levels don’t show, or always read empty even though the cartridge is full.
  • Colours differ from the original, noticeable mainly in photos and skin tones.
  • Leaks. A badly sealed compatible cartridge can leak into the printer and soil the mechanism.
  • Clogged print heads, on models where the head is part of the printer rather than the cartridge. Unsuitable ink can dry out or clog the nozzles, and replacing the head is an expensive repair.

What happens to the warranty

Read the printer manufacturer’s warranty terms, because they differ from brand to brand. A fault caused directly by a compatible cartridge, for example a leak that ruined the mechanism, may not be covered. If the printer is new and under warranty, keep the cartridge that caused the problem and the receipt.

How to compare properly: cost per page

A cartridge’s price on its own tells you little. What matters is how many pages it prints. Manufacturers state the cartridge’s page yield on the box or their website: the approximate number of pages, measured with a standardised method at a set page coverage.

The sum is simple: divide the cartridge price by the stated number of pages. That gives you the cost per page, and you can compare:

  • a standard original against a high-capacity original (usually marked “XL”), which often has a much lower cost per page;
  • the original against a compatible, if the compatible’s maker states a yield measured with the same method;
  • your printer’s cost per page against that of an ink tank printer.

Be wary of compatibles that promise very high yields without saying how they were measured. And plain text uses far less ink than a page of photos, so for photos the real yield drops a lot.

Original or compatible, depending on your situation

When to choose originals

The original is usually the better choice in a few situations:

  • You print photos you want to keep for years.
  • The printer is new and under warranty.
  • The print head is part of the printer, not the cartridge, and an ink problem would mean a repair.
  • You print rarely. The cost difference matters little, and a low-quality compatible dries out more easily between uses.
  • You need documents that look identical every time, for example for a small business run from home.

When compatibles make sense

A good compatible is a reasonable choice when:

  • you print a lot of text, school worksheets, work documents;
  • the printer is older and out of warranty;
  • the print head is in the cartridge, so a poor compatible only affects you until the next cartridge;
  • you’ve already found a compatible brand that works well with your model.

How to choose a better compatible:

  • Buy from a seller who offers a return or replacement if the printer doesn’t recognise the cartridge.
  • Check the exact cartridge code, not just the printer name. Models with almost identical names use different cartridges.
  • Read reviews for your exact printer model, not for the compatible brand in general.
  • Avoid switching between brands endlessly. When you find one that works, stick with it.

Laser printers and compatible toner

In laser printers, toner is a powder, not a liquid, so it doesn’t dry out or clog nozzles. Good-quality compatible or remanufactured toner is widely used, especially for text.

The risks are different: poor toner can leave smudges, grey streaks or powder inside the printer. On many models the drum is replaced separately from the toner cartridge, and repeating streaks can come from a worn drum rather than the toner. It’s worth checking before you blame the cartridge. For other printing problems, see our guide to fixing a printer that’s not printing.

When you change the toner, take the old one out slowly, keeping it level, and put it in the new cartridge’s bag. Toner powder is hard to clean off clothes and furniture, and shouldn’t be picked up with an ordinary vacuum cleaner. Some shops and manufacturers take empty cartridges back for recycling, and some remanufacturing companies actively look for them.

The alternative: an ink tank printer

If you print a lot in colour and the cost of cartridges bothers you, a different printer might make sense. Ink tank models cost more to buy, but they’re filled from bottles and the cost per page is usually much lower than with cartridges. Compare the manufacturer’s stated cost per page, as above.

Two things to know. Ink tank printers also have print heads that can dry out if left unused for weeks. And if you only print a few pages a month, the higher purchase price takes a very long time to pay back.

For an office or small business, where people print a lot and scan often, the picture changes. Our guide to choosing an office multifunction printer covers that case.

How to keep cartridges and your printer in good shape

Whichever cartridges you choose, a few habits make the printer last longer and waste less ink:

  • Switch the printer off with its button, not at the wall. A normal shutdown parks and caps the print head so it doesn’t dry out.
  • Print regularly. One colour page a week keeps the nozzles open. Printers left unused for months often end up running repeated cleaning cycles, which use a lot of ink.
  • Don’t take cartridges out without a reason. Each time exposes the contacts and nozzles to air and dust.
  • Keep spare cartridges sealed, at room temperature, away from sunlight and radiators.
  • Run head cleaning only when needed. If the test page looks fine, don’t run it again.
  • Pick the right print mode. For worksheets and drafts, “economy” or “draft” mode uses much less ink. For black-and-white text, choose black-only printing so the printer doesn’t mix in colours.

If you print very rarely, sending the occasional document to a print shop can be cheaper than keeping an inkjet that dries out between uses. A black-and-white laser printer, on the other hand, can sit for months without trouble.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my printer say it’s out of ink when the cartridge is new?

With compatibles, the chip may not be read correctly. Take the cartridge out, gently clean the gold contacts with a dry, lint-free cloth and put it back. If it still isn’t recognised, try unplugging the printer for a minute. With originals, check you’ve removed the protective tape.

Is it worth refilling cartridges at home?

You can, but it’s messy and unpredictable. Cartridges with a built-in head survive a limited number of refills before the nozzles fail, and the chip may keep showing “empty”. For people who print little, it’s rarely worth the effort.

Do compatible cartridges damage the printer?

A good-quality compatible rarely damages anything. The real risk comes from cartridges that leak, or from inks unsuited to printers with a fixed print head. That’s why the compatible’s manufacturer matters more than the fact that it’s compatible.

How long does an opened cartridge last?

Once fitted, an ink cartridge can dry out if the printer sits unused for a long time. Print a colour page at least once a week so the nozzles stay clear. Sealed cartridges usually have an expiry date on the box.

What does IT support for a printer involve?

Setting it up on your computer, phone and Wi-Fi, choosing the right cartridges, cleaning and diagnosing errors. See more examples of IT services for home and office.

When to ask for help

Ask for help if the printer rejects cartridges after an update, if ink has leaked inside it, if prints still come out streaky after head cleaning, or if you don’t know which cartridge or toner code you need.

We source the right cartridges or toner for your model, original or compatible as you prefer, and set the printer up on your computer, phone and Wi-Fi. Details are on our home IT services page.

Tell us what is not working

Describe the problem in a few lines. We reply with what we think needs doing and what it would cost.

Describe the problem